[X] CLOSEMAIN MENU

[X] CLOSEIN THIS SECTION

Birth Defects Research and Resources

Three of the 120+ children suffering from the devastating effects of Agent Orange living at Friendship Village outside of Hanoi, Vietnam; image from Alan Strakey at Creative Commons.

Birth defects, also known as congenital malformations, are abnormalities present at birth.1 Many birth defects pose profound physical, mental, social and economic hardships on the affected individuals and their families. As of 2013, birth defects were the leading cause of infant mortality in the US and the second-leading cause of under-five mortality.2 We present an introduction to research on genetic and environmental contributors to major birth defects.

Types of Birth Defects

Structural Defects

Common Structural Birth Defects

Congenital Heart Defects

Congenital heart defects are conditions present at birth which cause the blood to move through the heart in an abnormal fashion.3 Many forms of congenital heart defects involve abnormalities in the valves of the heart, interior walls, and arteries and veins moving the blood from or to the heart. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) reports that congenital heart defects affect eight of every 1,000 US births, making congenital heart defects the most common type of birth defect.4

Oral Clefts

Oral clefts, otherwise termed orofacial clefts, are a subcategory of facial birth defect made up of cleft lip and cleft palate.5 The facial birth defects result from an incomplete joining of the tissue forming the facial structure. Oral clefts can occur alone (isolated) or alongside other birth defects. Isolated oral clefts are one of the most common birth defects in the US. About 2,650 US infants (cleft palate) and 4,440 (cleft lip with or without cleft palate) are estimated born in the US annually.6

Upper and Lower Limb Reduction

When developing fetuses’ arms (upper limbs) or legs (lower limbs) form abnormally or fail to present at all, the fetus has an upper or lower limb reduction defect. Upper limb reduction defects are estimated to be about twice as common as lower limb reduction defects, with an annual prevalence of four out of every 1000 live births within the US (upper) and two out of every 1000 live births (lower).7

Spina Bifida

Spina bifida is a category of neural tube defect in which the neural tube fails to develop properly or does not close completely, causing the backbone to form abnormally.8 Multiple types of spina bifida are defined by their physical presentation. The three most common forms:

  • Myelomenigocele: the most severe form, defined by the occurrence of a sac of fluid containing part of the spinal cord protruding from an individual’s back.
  • Menignocele: individuals with menignocele spina bifida also present with a protruding sac of fluid but the sac does not contain any part of the spinal cord.
  • Spina bifida occulta: also known as hidden spina bifida, this form lacks an external sac but presents with only an internal gap within the spinal cord.

    9

All together, spina bifida is estimated to affect 1,500 American births per year.10
Show MoreHide

Structural defects affect the formation of parts of the body and are defined by physical abnormalities in one or more parts of the body. They present at birth and result in a physical disability such as an oral cleft, spina bifida, congenital heart defects, and upper and lower limb reduction. Historically, structural birth defects have been classified as either major or minor.11

Depending on where you look or with whom you speak, the term birth defect may include only structural birth defects. While not consistently used by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), this limited definition is used in the CDC’s birth defect prevalence estimates.12

Other Types of Defects

A broader definition is used by many health organizations and includes other forms of abnormalities present at birth:

Tay-Sachs Disease and PKU

In Tay-Sachs disease, babies lack an enzyme needed to break down certain fatty substances in brain cells. These substances build up and destroy brain cells, resulting in blindness, paralysis and death by age five.13

Babies with PKU cannot process phenylalanine, an amino acid (a building block of proteins) which then builds up in the blood and causes brain damage. PKU is routinely detected with newborn screening tests, so affected babies can be placed on a special diet that prevents intellectual disability.14

  • Some organizations, such as the National Institutes of Health, consider functional defects as birth defects if they result from one or more adverse events during fetal development. Functional defects, also known as developmental birth defects, can affect the nervous system, immune system, endocrine system or other systems of the body, and may not become apparent for months or years.15
  • The World Health Organization and NIH consider metabolic defects16 a subset of functional birth defects.17 These defects involve abnormalities in an individual’s body chemistry. Two prominent metabolic birth defects are Tay-Sachs disease18 and phenylketonuria (PKU).19
  • Considered by some to be birth defects, non-disabling defects are abnormalities that do not necessarily result in a disability, although they may be unwanted or cosmetically disfiguring, such as an extra finger. Small structural abnormalities should not be taken lightly, however, as they may be an external sign of future functional issues.

The table below demonstrates that defining defects is complex and often overlapping. One defect may present with multiple forms of abnormalities. Further complicating the definition of birth defect are comorbidities—the presence of two or more conditions concurrently—which are common within individuals with birth defects.20

Common Birth Defects21

Functional22

Structural23

Metabolic24

Degenerative Disorders

Autism spectrum disorders*

ADHD*

Cerebral palsy*

Down syndrome*

Fetal alcohol syndrome*

Fragile X syndrome*

Hearing loss*

Impaired vision*
Intellectual disabilities*

Learning disabilities*

Prader-Willi syndrome

Anencephaly

Anotia/microtia

Cleft lip / cleft palate

Congenital heart defects

Craniosynostosis

Down syndrome*

Encephalocele

Fetal alcohol syndrome*

Gastroschisis

Hypospadias*

Lower limb reduction defects

Microcephaly

Omphalocele

Sickle cell disease

Spina bifida

Upper limb reduction defects

Argininosuccinic acidemia

Citrullinemia

Homocystinuria

Maple syrup urine disease

Phenylketonuria (PKU)

Rett syndrome*

Muscular dystrophy

X-ALD

*These conditions are discussed in more detail on other webpages on this site, as linked.

Prevalence of Birth Defects

The use of various definitions of birth defects, coupled with varying methods of tracking defects, if at all, results in considerable uncertainty regarding the incidence and prevalence of defects. The March of Dimes estimates that six percent of all newborns are born with a serious genetic or partially genetic birth defect globally.25

Underreporting of Birth Defects

Some evidence indicates that US rates may be higher than those from the CDC.26

Data on birth defects are not collected uniformly or completely. Inconsistencies in birth defect record collection include these:27

  • One-fifth of US states lack any system for tracking birth defects.
  • Within states that do track, how babies are identified and diagnosed is not consistent.
  • The CDC funds population-based tracking in only 14 states, and tracking is limited to major birth defects (structural).
  • Many states use passive tracking systems, or systems in which reporting is voluntary.
  • States do not track functional defects in the same way they do structural defects. Existing reporting programs rely upon medical records collected in 14 or fewer communities and national surveys.
  • Most birth defect research and monitoring efforts have focused on major structural abnormalities such as oral clefts, heart defects, spina bifida and limb defects.
  • Differences in definitions add to the challenges faced by those who study the causes of birth defects and changes over time.
Show MoreHide

In the US, the CDC reports that according to medical records, three percent—one in every 33 births or about 120,000 children annually—has a major structural or genetic birth defect.28 The large discrepancy between the US and global estimates may be due to a combination of multiple factors, such as wealth, infection rate, nutrition and other environmental factors.29 Access to health care and diagnostic facilities may also affect reporting rates across geographic areas.30

Because birth defects are not consistently identified and recorded across locations and time periods, summaries of prevalence and trends are elusive. This graph provides a snapshot view of structural defects at one place and time:31

Birth Defects Prevalence In Hungary, 1980

data from March of Dimes;32 click to zoom

A 2008 investigation in Atlanta, Georgia, determined that the distribution of birth defects was not even throughout the population, with the prevalence differing by both gender and race/ethnicity. However, the higher prevalence among males decreased when defects that occur almost exclusively in males (such as hypospadias) were excluded.33 A 2006 global report found that families of low socioeconomic status have increased rates of birth defects.34

Causes of Birth Defects

Both genetic and environmental factors contribute to the total incidence of birth defects, but the percentage attributable to each is not known.35 The cause of approximately 50 percent of birth defects is unknown.36

Genetics

DNA model

image from Caroline Davis2010 at Creative Commons

Birth defects can be caused by abnormalities in genetic material, including gene sequence changes (mutations) and changes in the number of chromosomes.37 Abnormalities may be passed along from the ancestral line (inherited) or result from random mutation within one or both parents' gametes (egg and sperm), an abnormal reproductive cell formation, or from chromosomal damage in the developing embryo.38

Top Genetic Birth Defects Worldwide39

Single gene defects

  • Common recessive disorders
    • The hemoglobin disorders: sickle cell anemia and thalassemia
    • Oculocutaneous albinism
    • Cystic fibrosis
  • 3.6 per 1,000 live births in high-income countries, with higher rates in many middle- and low-income countries
  • Cystic fibrosis prevalence is approximately one in 2,000 live births in Caucasian populations.
  • Other conditions classified as rare single gene defects are evident in one (or fewer) in 10,000 births.

Genetic predisposition to hemolysis and neonatal jaundice

  • Examples:
    • Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency
    • Rhesus negativity
  • An estimated 7.5 percent of the world's population carries a G6PD gene
  • In high-income countries, Rhesus negativity has been almost completely eliminated by Rhesus blood grouping for all pregnant women and treatment, but the problem seems to have received relatively little attention in some lower-income countries.

Chromosomal disorders

  • Example: Down syndrome
  • As high as two to three per 1,000 live births in middle- and low-income countries and as low as 1.2 per 1,000 live births in high-income countries
Show MoreHide

Inherited genetic birth defects are either recessive or dominant, indicating the effect of a copy of a gene on the phenotype (physical expression) of that gene. Humans are diploid organisms, having two copies of each gene. A defect is dominant if a defect occurs when only one of the two gene copies within a person malfunctions. Recessive defects require both gene copies to malfunction for the defect to occur.40

Both dominant and recessive defects can be either X-linked (the malfunctioning gene is located on the X chromosome) or autosomal (the malfunctioning gene is located on one of the other 22 chromosomes. The inheritance pattern of X-linked and autosomal defects is dependent on their dominance.41

human embryo

image from Ed Uthman at Creative Commons

Environmental Factors

Teratogens—agents which can cause a birth defect—are broadly categorized into five groups:42

  1. Physical agents such as radiation
  2. Environmental pollutants
  3. Drugs, both medicinal and recreational
  4. Maternal illness or disturbances of the mother's metabolism
  5. Maternal infections

We provide a brief overview of each of these, of interactions among them and of how timing may influence their impacts.

Physical and Chemical Agents and Drugs

Timing and Critical Windows of Susceptibility

According to the World Health Organization, a critical window of susceptibility is a "sensitive time interval during development when environmental exposures can interfere with physiology of cell, tissue, or organ." These windows include periods in which cells are growing rapidly, tissues are forming, and the young body is still without most protective capabilities, such as an immune system, blood brain barrier or DNA repair system.

The timing of some exposures can influence or determine the effect. For example, an embryo exposed to the drug thalidomide between the 24th and 33rd day of gestation often suffers severe limb deformities, while those exposed at other times have either no or different health effects. Earlier exposure to thalidomide, approximately 20-23 days after conception, increases the risk of an infant missing an ear.43

Similarly, the effect of radiation exposure depends on the timing. In the first two weeks of gestation, the greatest concern from modest exposure (below the level needed to make the mother sick) is death of the embryo. From two to 18 weeks of gestation, birth defects, especially those involving the brain, are most likely. After 18 weeks gestation, the risk of birth defects is reduced except from much larger doses of radiation.44 Cleft palate defects also show sensitivity to the timing of exposure.45

The Critical Windows of Development46 timeline from The Endocrine Disruption Exchange47 shows how exposures to certain chemicals can affect various anatomical systems at different stages of prenatal development.

Show MoreHide

CHE's Toxicant and Disease Database provides a list of exposures associated with selected structural birth defects. We have summarized the list of toxicants in this table, supplemented from other sources as noted. This list is not exhaustive, and many further chemicals and agents have not been studied sufficiently to determine their roles in birth defects. For definitions of the strength of evidence and more information about the database, see About the Toxicant and Disease Database. More information about specific toxicants is on the linked pages.

Defect Strong Evidence Good Evidence
Congenital malformations—general

Anesthetic gases

Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)

Ionizing radiation

Thalidomide48

Agent Orange

Air pollution49

Arsenic

Carbon monoxide

Diethylstilbestrol (DES)50

Dilantin51

Ecstasy—MDMA52

Mercury

Methamphetamine53

Nitrates54

Solvents, including ethylene glycol ethers

Tobacco smoke

Cardiac congenital malformations

Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)

Anesthetic gases

Solvents, including trichloroethylene (TCE)

Tobacco smoke

Cranio-facial malformations Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)

Toluene

Ionizing radiation

Mercury

PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls), not otherwise specified

Solvents, including ethylene glycol ethers

Fetal alcohol syndrome / fetal solvent syndrome Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)
Toluene
Solvents
Neural tube defects / central nervous system (CNS) malformations   Arsenic

Chlorination byproducts, including trihalomethanes

Chlorophenols

Mercury

Oral clefts (cleft lip and palate)  

Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)

Tobacco smoke

Skeletal malformations Ethyl alcohol (ethanol)

Arsenic

Molinate

Further toxicants with limited evidence of associations are listed in the Toxicant and Disease Database.

Drug therapy needed for a woman's health and well-being can Increase risks of birth defects. A few examples:

prescription drugs

image from sharyn morrow at Creative Commons

  • Anticonvulsant drugs, including sodium valproate and phenytoin, for maternal epilepsy can increase the risk of major malformations, growth retardation and hypoplasia of the midface and fingers, known as anticonvulsant embryopathy. In developing countries, the fetus of an epileptic mother is at greater risk because anti-epileptic therapy is less likely to be well-controlled, multiple drug therapy is more common, and less-expensive but more teratogenic drugs are more likely to be used.55
  • Anti-thyroid drugs taken during specific weeks of pregnancy can lead to birth defects including abnormalities in skin and facial features, structural defects such as choanal and esophageal atresia, and psychomotor delay.56
  • Isotretinoin (Accutane), a drug used to treat severe acne, is associated with malformations involving craniofacial, cardiac, thymic and central nervous system structures.57

Maternal Illness and Altered Maternal Metabolism

Birth defects are more frequent in children of mothers who have preexisting chronic diseases including diabetes and hypertension. Uncontrolled maternal insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) increases the risk of heart defects and neural tube defects, affecting 0.5 percent of pregnancies (one in 200) in high-income countries and higher rates in populatons with poor diabetes control.58

Infection and Infectious Disease

Certain infections in pregnant women can damage the fetus or infant:59

Rubella and Birth Defects

Rubella (sometimes called (German measles) is a contagious, viral disease that causes mild flu-like symptoms and a skin rash in about half of all infected individuals. While generally mild in adults, rubella can have a much greater impact on an embryo. Infection with rubella in the first trimester of pregnancy can result in multiple birth defects, known as congenital rubella syndrome. Abnormalities may include these:60

  • Cataracts or other eye defects, such as retinopathy
  • Deafness
  • Developmental delay
  • Low birth weight
  • Intellectual disability
  • Seizures
  • Small head size (microcephaly)
  • Heart defects

Due to childhood vaccination requirements, rubella has been eliminated in the US and many other developed countries. It remains common in other countries.61

Show MoreHide

Toxoplasmosis and Birth Defects

The parasitic disease toxoplasmosis, transmitted through raw meat and cat feces, can cause serious defects in a fetus. Children with congenital toxoplasmosis may develop disabling complications, including hearing loss, mental disability and blindness. Most infected infants do not have symptoms at birth but can develop serious symptoms later in life Occasionally infected newborns have serious eye or brain damage at birth.62

A mother's immunity developed through prior Toxoplasma infection will generally protect a fetus during development. However, some experts advise delaying pregnancy for six months following a Toxoplasma infection.63

Show MoreHide
  • Toxoplasmosis can cause intrauterine growth restriction, prematurity and other impacts on the fetus (see the box at right).
  • Hepatitis can cause chronic subclinical disease in later childhood or adulthood.
  • Syphilis can cause a variety of effects including skin lesions, blindness, brain damage, sensorineural deafness and dental deformities.
  • HIV/AIDS leads to progressive immunologic deterioration and opportunistic infections and cancers.
  • Zika virus is associated with microcephaly, with some babies also developing swallowing difficulties, epileptic seizures, bone deformities and vision and hearing problems.
  • Varicella-Zoster virus can lead to congenital varicella syndrome, marked by underdeveloped arms and legs, eye inflammation, and incomplete brain development.
  • Human parvovirus B19 causes fifth disease, which can impair the fetal ability to make red blood cells, leading to dangerous anemia and heart failure.

Nutrition

Both maternal malnutrition and obesity increase the risk of birth defects.64 Some specific micronutrient deficiencies are well documented to cause birth defects.

Folic acid is a B vitamin important for cell growth and preventing anemia. It is also required for epigenetic replication and programming. A deficiency of folic acid during pregnancy can lead to neural tube defects such as anencephaly, spina bifida and encephalocele. Women are recommended to take 400 micrograms of folic acid prior to pregnancy and 600 micrograms during pregnancy. In the mid 1990s the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) began requiring manufacturers to fortify grain products such as breads, flours and rice with folic acid; as of 2016, corn masa flour has been added to this list.65

iodized salt

image from Harry Pujols at Creative Commons

Maternal iodine deficiency may cause miscarriage or other pregnancy complications, such as premature delivery and infertility. Iodine is also one of the most important minerals required by a fetus for brain and cognitive development, and even a moderate deficiency can cause deficits. When a deficiency is very severe, the effect on cognitive development can be up to 15 IQ points lower than normal.66

Perhaps two billion people worldwide have insufficient iodine intake.67 UNICEF considers iodine deficiency the single most important cause of preventable brain damage and intellectual disability, with most cases caused before birth.68 Fortification of salt with iodine has been one of the most successful nutrition interventions to date, with more than 70 percent of global households having access to iodized salt.69

For more information about nutrition, see our Food and Agriculture Environment webpage.

Demographics

Birth defects by race and sex

data on major structural and genetic birth defects from the CDC;70 click to zoom

Race, ethnicity and parental age are all risk factors for birth defects.71 A 2014 study on race and major birth defects found that race and ethnicity were associated with numerous birth defects including anotia/microtia, spina bifida and Down syndrome. In comparison to non-Hispanic Whites, Cubans and Asians had a lower occurrence of many of the studied birth defects.72 However, the study did not adjust for known risk factors such as socioeconomic status, nutrition level or access to medical care. Without controlling for such confounders, conclusions regarding the underlying cause of the difference in prevalence between the races and ethnicities are speculative.

Maternal age is associated with an increased risk of some birth defects, with different risks seen in younger and older mothers:73

family

image from Kamaljith K V at Creative Commons

  • Older (over 34 years old) women are at increased risk of bearing a child with chromosomal abnormalities such as Down syndrome or non-chromosomal abnormalities such as non-chromosomal heart defects.74
  • Younger (teenage) women are at higher risk for a child with gastroschisis, premature birth or impaired fetal growth.75 Premature birth and impaired fetal growth are associated with several structural and functional birth defects.76

While less understood and rarely discussed, paternal age is also a risk factor for birth defects. Most likely due to age-related genetic mutation, older men are more likely to father children with functional and structural birth defects.77 Birth defects associated with older paternal age include Down syndrome,78 Crouzon syndrome and Pfeiffer syndrome.79

Interacting Factors

Multifactorial Inheritance

Birth defects due to complex genetic and environmental interaction are termed multifactorial inheritance. Perhaps 20 to 30 percent of all defects fall into this category. Multifactorial birth defects are usually malformations of a single organ system or limb and include congenital heart disease, neural tube defects, cleft lip and/or cleft palate, clubfoot and developmental dysplasia of the hip.

Major multifactorial congenital malformations:

  • Congenital heart defects are the most common form of birth defect, occurring at a rate of four to eight per 1,000 live births. The majority of congenital heart defects have a multifactorial cause.
  • Neural tube defects—including spina bifida, anencephaly and encephalocoele—have been recorded as high as six per 1,000 live births in China, but varying widely depending on genetic and environmental condition.
  • Multifactorial inheritance accounts for the majority of cleft lip, with or without cleft palate, with birth prevalence ranging from 0.3 per 1,000 live births in Black American populations, one per 1,000 in Whites, two per 1,000 in Japanese to 3.6 per 1,000 live births in Native North Americans.80
Show MoreHide

A growing number of experts believe that many birth defects result from a combination of multiple factors, such as an interaction between one or more genes, behavioral factors, and the prenatal or preconception environments.81 Environmental factors and genetic material interact in numerous ways to form birth defects.

Genetics and Epigenetic Programming

As with most chronic diseases, genetic variants play a role in fetal development, causing some birth defects. However, having a specific gene variant, or set of variants, does not always mean that an individual will have a defect. Often with genetic components of diseases and disorders, an individual's environment—nutrition, activity, chemical exposures, sleep quality and so on—can either promote or inhibit the physical expression of genes.

The term "epigenetic programming" refers to mechanisms that can turn on or off genes or sections of chromosomes, changing their functioning. These changes are maintained as the cell replicates, and some research has shown that these changes can pass down to offspring. Changes in a fetus's genes by the mother's nutritional status during pregnancy are an example of epigenetic programming.

See the Gene-Environment Interactions webpage for more information.

Show MoreHide

The mother's ability to metabolize exposures can influence their effects. In some cases, the mother's metabolism is governed by her gene variants (see more about gene variants on our Gene-Environment Interactions webpage):

  • Phenylketonuria is an inborn inability to metabolize the amino acid phenylalanine. If a woman with this genetic variant does not follow a special diet, she may carry high levels of phenylalanine and its metabolites. The presence of these metabolites during pregnancy can lead to fetal death, growth retardation, microcephaly and intellectual disability.82
  • BPA is associated with birth defects in animal studies, but the strength of association is associated with the mother's ability to metabolize BPA.83

While prenatal alcohol exposure is a necessary factor for the development of fetal alcohol syndrome, the risk also depends on a mother's alcohol metabolic process, which in turn is influenced by her genetics and her nutritional status.84

mother and child

image from DFID UK Department for International Development

Pregnancies in middle- and low-income countries, in comparison to high-income countries, are more likely to be at risk from potential teratogens for several reasons:85

  • Increased frequency of intrauterine infection
  • Poor maternal nutrition
  • Low socioeconomic and educational levels
  • Lack of environmental protection policies
  • Poorly regulated access to medication

Paternal Exposures

Environmental factors experienced by the father can also impact gene expression. Birth defects associated with paternal exposures are termed paternal-mediated birth defects or male-mediated teratogenesis. Research on this topic is more limited than on maternal-mediated birth defects, but evidence is mounting.86

In 2013, a large case-control study was conducted with National Birth Defects Prevention Study data, looking at associations between paternal occupation and birth defects. The study found statistically significant associations between specific birth defects and several paternal professions and occupations:87

father and child

image from texasgurl at Creative Commons

  • Mathematical, physical and computer scientists
  • Artists
  • Photographers and photo processors
  • Food service workers
  • Landscapers and groundskeepers
  • Hairdressers and cosmetologists
  • Office and administrative support workers
  • Sawmill workers
  • Petroleum and gas workers
  • Chemical workers
  • Printers
  • Material moving equipment operators
  • Motor vehicle operators

A 2016 review found that preconception paternal exposures to factors such as alcohol, limited diet and cigarette smoking were associated with birth defects. They conclude that, as with the mother, the environment of the father can impacts the gene expression of their offspring for generations to come.88

Research

As of 2016, major studies and ongoing initiatives in the US are examining exposures and other risk factors for birth defects:89

Other research programs and initiatives are listed in the Dig Deeper section in the right sidebar.

Challenges in Associating Environmental Factors with Birth Defects

Researchers face many challenges when assessing the connections between environmental factors and birth defects. A few of these challenges:

  • Only a tiny fraction of commonly encountered chemicals have been tested for their ability to cause human health impacts, including birth defects.90

graphic of chemical testing

  • Even with new pesticides and pharmaceutical drugs, which undergo more extensive testing than most other chemicals, tests are often not sensitive enough to identify less obvious birth defects, including many functional defects. Because pregnant women are not commonly included in drug safety testing, only very limited data are available on the effects of pharmaceutical drugs taken during pregnancy. Evidence can be very slow to accumulate and reach a threshold of showing harm. A 2011 review found that the mean time for a treatment initially classified as having an "undetermined" risk to be assigned a more precise risk was 27 years.91

laboratory animals

image from Sarah Laval at Creative Commons

  • Laboratory animals used in birth defect etiology research are genetically very similar to each other and have carefully controlled diets and exposures. These tests can provide evidence of association within these controlled environments but cannot always predict what will happen in the real world, which is far more complex and diverse. Many factors confound or mediate the associations between environmental toxicants and birth defects, including genetic traits, parental age, lifestyles, health conditions and additional exposures.92

mother and child

image drom DR. BEN LUNA at Creative Commons

  • Interactions among multiple factors (chemicals, genes, nutrition, infections, health conditions) make it hard to pinpoint the contribution of one factor. Not all people are equally susceptible to birth defects; genetic and nutritional factors may combine with other environmental factors to increase the risk. This combination of factors makes it difficult to accurately identify associations between birth defects and toxicants, especially when the risk factors are not well understood or hard to measure.93
  • Study participants are commonly unable to accurately recollect their exposures. This may lead to biased association estimates.94
  • If the timing of potentially harmful exposures is not known precisely, a link between birth defects and environmental factors may be missed.
  • Certain birth defects are rare, making it hard to design studies powerful enough to reliably detect associations. One way to increase study power—the statistical ability to correctly accept the test hypothesis—is to increase the sample size. In order to increase sample sizes, researcher may lump together defects that are similar in some regards but may have different etiologies. Doing so decreases the study sensitivity or the ability to detect an existing association.95 For example, heart defects are often considered as a single category, but within this group are individual kinds of defects that may have distinct environmental associations.
  • Some birth defects are not apparent until years or decades after birth.
  • There is no comprehensive global or even national system for monitoring or reporting birth defects.96

Costs of Birth Defects

An analysis by the California Birth Defects Monitoring Program estimated lifetime costs for children born in 1992 in the US with one or more of 18 significant major birth defects, including cerebral palsy, at approximately $8 billion (in 1992 dollars).97 More recent data are available from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,98 but a comprehensive analysis has not been published since 1998.

Social and Inclusion Issues

The term "birth defects" carries a connotation within our society that many individuals feel is harmful. A 2007 survey found that "birth defect" was the overall first choice preferred term, yet it was first choice for fewer than half of both affected (self or a family member with a birth defect, with 28.5 percent selecting this term) and unaffected people (35.4 percent selecting).99

Preference for birth defects terms

data from Mai et al.;100 click to zoom

Specific birth defects carry their own negative connotations and stigmas, with stigmas focused on both the affected individual and the parental role in the defect acquisition. The National Organization on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome has a “Stamp out Stigma” campaign focused on removing the stigmas facing all individuals affected by fetal alcohol syndrome, from the child to birth and adopted parents. That campaign notes that the stigma is so negative and pervasive that some doctors will purposely misdiagnose children with FAS as having ADHD or bipolar disorder in an effort to reduce the social impact of the disease. For more information please see the Statement on Stigma of FASD and Circle of Hope pages.

Despite continued stigmas and negative connotations surrounding birth defects, progress is evident over the last 60 years toward including and providing proper support to individuals with birth defects. Current US law prohibits discrimination in regards to employment and ensures access to specialized educational and early development services. For more information on the history of disability laws please refer to the Legal History section of the Learning and Developmental Disabilities Research and Resources webpage.

Conclusion

We know that the developing embryo and fetus are extraordinarily and uniquely vulnerable to environmental exposures. Prenatal exposures and conditions can not only result in structural birth defects but can also impact the function of the nervous, immune, reproductive and other systems

Environmental exposures experienced by men and women throughout their lifetimes can lead to chromosomal abnormalities impacting the health of their offspring. Additionally, the toxicants accumulated by a woman throughout her life and during pregnancy can transfer in large quantities to the developing embryo and fetus, at times when exposures have the greatest impact.

The "better safe than sorry" approach of the precautionary principle should be taken when dealing with chemicals that may cause birth defects. Both individual action and prevention from government and industry—free from societal judgment—are needed to safeguard individuals and families.

More information about birth defects can be found in the resources in the right sidebar.


This page was last revised by practicum student Maggie Lind and Nancy Hepp, with review by Betty Mekdeci, in March 2017. Read more about Maggie's practicum, including her review summary.

CHE invites our partners to submit corrections and clarifications to this page. Please include links to research to support your submissions through the comment form on our Contact page.

View All Footnotes